New York Slip and Fall Lawyer
Reviewed by John F. Harwick, Managing Partner, Hacker Murphy LLP. Admitted in New York and in the U.S. District Courts for the Northern, Eastern, Western, and Southern Districts of New York. Last reviewed September 2026.
Almost every New York slip and fall case turns on one question: did the property owner know, or should they have known, about the hazard in time to fix it. A wet floor or an icy walk is not enough on its own. Proving notice is the case, and the evidence that proves it disappears fast.
Hacker Murphy represents people injured in falls across New York State from offices in Albany, Troy, Schenectady, and Saratoga Springs. Call 518-274-5820 for a free consultation.
Notice Is the Whole Case
New York property owners owe visitors a duty of reasonable care. That duty is not a guarantee against accidents. To recover, you have to show the owner had notice of the dangerous condition, and there are two ways to do it.
Actual notice
The owner or their staff knew about the hazard. A manager was told about the leak. A prior customer reported it. An employee saw the spill and walked past it. Maintenance logs, prior complaints, and repair requests are where actual notice lives, and they are usually in the defendant’s hands, which is why they have to be demanded early and in writing.
Constructive notice
The owner should have known. New York’s standard comes from Gordon v. American Museum of Natural History, decided March 25, 1986, which holds that “to constitute constructive notice, a defect must be visible and apparent and it must exist for a sufficient length of time prior to the accident to permit defendant’s employees to discover and remedy it.”
Two elements, both required. Visible and apparent, meaning a reasonable inspection would have caught it. And there long enough, meaning the owner had a real chance to fix it. A puddle that appeared thirty seconds before you fell fails the second element no matter how obvious it was.
This is why the timing evidence matters more than the photograph of the hazard. Dirt tracked through a spill, melted and refrozen ice, a worn-down tread, a stain around the edge of a puddle, all of these speak to how long the condition existed. So does surveillance video, which many businesses overwrite within days.
Snow and Ice Falls: The Storm in Progress Rule
If you fell on snow or ice in New York, expect the defense to raise the storm in progress doctrine before anything else. It is the single most common defense in an upstate winter fall, and most injured people have never heard of it.
The rule comes from the Court of Appeals in Solazzo v. New York City Transit Authority, decided December 20, 2005: “a property owner will not be held liable in negligence for a plaintiff’s injuries sustained as the result of an icy condition occurring during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time thereafter.”
In plain terms, an owner does not have to clear snow during a storm or for a reasonable time after the storm ends.
The rule has limited exceptions, such as if the fall was caused by old ice predating the ongoing storm, or if there were negligent removal efforts that created or worsened the condition.
Falls on Sidewalks and Public Property
If you fell on a municipal sidewalk, in a public park, or on any property owned by a city, town, village, county, or the State, two extra requirements apply and both can end a claim before it begins.
A notice of claim within 90 days. General Municipal Law § 50-e requires a notice of claim to be served “within ninety days after the claim arises.” Miss it and the claim is generally barred, three years of limitations period notwithstanding.
Prior written notice. Most New York municipalities have a prior written notice law, and it is a genuine trap. Under Town Law § 65-a, an action against a town for a defective or unsafe condition generally requires proof that “written notice of such defective, unsafe, dangerous or obstructed condition … was actually given to the town clerk or town superintendent of highways,” followed by the town’s failure to repair within a reasonable time. Villages and cities have parallel provisions.
What that means practically: unless somebody had already complained in writing about that specific defect, and the municipality did nothing, the claim against the municipality may fail regardless of how dangerous the condition was. The town clerk keeps an indexed record of these notices, and checking it is one of the first steps in a sidewalk case.
There are recognized exceptions, including where the municipality itself created the defect through affirmative negligence. Those exceptions are fact-specific and worth evaluating rather than assuming the claim is dead.
Where a sidewalk abuts private property, the abutting owner may carry the duty instead, depending on the local code. Identifying the right defendant early is what preserves the claim.
Defenses You Should Expect
Knowing these in advance is worth more than any argument made after the fact.
Open and obvious. The defense argues the hazard was so plain that you should have avoided it. In New York this generally goes to comparative fault rather than eliminating the duty, so it reduces a recovery rather than ending it.
Trivial defect. For sidewalk and floor cases, the defense argues the height difference was too small to be actionable. Courts look at width, depth, elevation, irregularity, and the circumstances of the injury rather than measuring against a fixed number. Photographs with a reference object of known size are what answer this.
Comparative fault. Your own inattention, footwear, or phone use reduces recovery proportionally under CPLR § 1411(a). Worth knowing: the 51 percent bar New York added in May 2026 applies only to claims subject to Article 51 of the Insurance Law, which means motor vehicle cases. Slip and fall claims remain pure comparative, so a share of blame reduces your recovery without cutting it off.
No notice. The most common and most serious defense, which is why the first section of this page is about notice.
What Is a New York Slip and Fall Case Worth?
There is no average worth quoting. Published figures blend a bruised knee with a hip fracture that ends someone’s independence, and New York does not publish settlement data. What drives value:
- Injury severity and permanence, supported by treating physician opinion
- Whether notice can be proved, which determines whether there is a case at all
- Available insurance, usually a commercial general liability or homeowners policy
- Your share of comparative fault
- Documented lost earnings, including future earning capacity
- Health insurance liens against the recovery
Notice is the binary variable here in a way it is not in a car accident case. A severe injury with no provable notice is worth less than a moderate injury with a maintenance log showing the hazard was reported twice.
What to Do After a Fall in New York
- Report it before you leave and ask for a written incident report. Get a copy or photograph it. An unreported fall is the defense’s first argument.
- Photograph the hazard immediately, with something of known size for scale, plus the surrounding area, lighting, and any warning signs or their absence.
- Photograph your footwear while you are still wearing what you fell in. The defense will ask about it months later.
- Get names and numbers of witnesses and employees who responded.
- Get medical care the same day and say you fell at the property.
- Ask that surveillance video be preserved, in writing. Many systems overwrite within days to weeks, and a written preservation request is what makes losing it consequential for the defendant.
- If it happened on public property, treat the 90-day clock as the real deadline.
- Do not give a recorded statement to the property’s insurer before speaking with a lawyer.
Deadlines in a New York Slip and Fall Claim
| What | Deadline | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Notice of claim against a municipality or public entity | 90 days | General Municipal Law § 50-e |
| Lawsuit against a private property owner | 3 years from the fall | CPLR § 214(5) |
| Wrongful death | 2 years from the date of death | EPTL § 5-4.1 |
| Claim on behalf of a child | Generally tolled until age 18 | CPLR § 208 |
The three-year period in CPLR § 214(5) is what most people know about. The 90-day municipal deadline is what actually ends cases.
Where Falls Happen
We handle falls at:
- Grocery stores, supermarkets, and big-box retail
- Restaurants and bars
- Apartment buildings, common areas, and stairwells
- Parking lots and parking garages
- Office buildings and medical facilities
- Hotels and motels
- Public sidewalks and municipal property
- Schools and campuses
- Private homes, through homeowners insurance
Stairway falls deserve a note. Building code violations involving riser height, tread depth, handrails, and lighting can support a claim independent of notice, because a code violation is evidence of negligence in itself. Our page on injuries from defective stairs covers those in more detail, and falls at a specific retailer come up often enough that we wrote about being injured at Walmart in New York.
Injuries We Handle
Falls produce injuries that are frequently more serious than people expect, particularly for older adults:
- Traumatic brain injury
- Spinal cord injury and paralysis
- Broken bones and fractures, especially hips, wrists, and ankles
- Serious back injuries
- Shoulder injuries
- Foot and ankle injuries
- Other catastrophic injuries
- Fatal falls and wrongful death claims
For the underlying legal framework, see our page on negligence claims in New York and on premises liability.
Slip and Fall Claims Across New York State
A slip and fall lawsuit is typically filed in the Supreme Court of the county where the fall happened or where the plaintiff resides. Supreme Court is New York’s trial court of general jurisdiction, not its highest court.
Our four offices sit in Albany, Rensselaer, Schenectady, and Saratoga counties:
- Albany attorneys
- Troy personal injury attorneys
- Schenectady personal injury attorneys
- Saratoga Springs personal injury attorneys
A full list is on our areas we serve page.
Frequently Asked Questions About New York Slip and Fall Claims
Is it hard to win a slip and fall case in New York?
Harder than most people expect, because the hazard alone proves nothing. You have to show the owner knew or should have known about it in time to fix it. Cases are won on maintenance records, surveillance video, prior complaints, and evidence of how long the condition existed.
What is constructive notice?
The rule from Gordon v. American Museum of Natural History: a defect must be visible and apparent, and it must have existed long enough before the accident for the owner’s employees to discover and fix it. Both elements are required. A hazard that appeared moments before your fall does not satisfy it.
Can I sue if I slipped on ice during a snowstorm?
Usually not for a fall during the storm itself. Under Solazzo v. New York City Transit Authority, an owner is not liable for an icy condition during an ongoing storm or for a reasonable time after. Limited exceptions exist, such as older ice or snow removal efforts that worsened the hazard.
How long do I have to file a slip and fall claim in New York?
Three years from the fall under CPLR § 214(5) for a private property owner. If you fell on municipal or state property, a notice of claim is generally required within 90 days under General Municipal Law § 50-e, and missing that usually bars the claim.
I fell on a city sidewalk. Do I have a case?
Possibly, but two extra hurdles apply. You need a notice of claim within 90 days, and most municipalities require proof that someone gave prior written notice of that specific defect and the municipality failed to fix it. Where the sidewalk abuts private property, the abutting owner may be the correct defendant instead.
What is the average slip and fall settlement in New York?
There is no meaningful average. Values range from minor to catastrophic and New York publishes no settlement data. What actually determines value is whether notice can be proved, the severity and permanence of the injury, the available insurance, and your share of comparative fault.
Does it hurt my case if the hazard was obvious?
It can reduce your recovery but generally does not eliminate the claim. New York treats an open and obvious condition as going to comparative fault rather than removing the owner’s duty. Under CPLR § 1411(a), slip and fall recoveries are reduced by your share of fault with no cutoff.
What if I was wearing sandals or looking at my phone?
The defense will raise it, and it may reduce your recovery proportionally. It does not bar the claim. Slip and fall cases remain pure comparative negligence in New York, unlike car accident claims since the May 2026 reform.
Should I report the fall even if I feel fine?
Yes, before you leave the property. Adrenaline masks injury and an unreported fall is the first thing the defense attacks. Ask for a written incident report and keep a copy or photograph of it.
What does a slip and fall lawyer cost?
Hacker Murphy handles slip and fall cases on a contingency fee. There is no fee unless there is a recovery, and the consultation is free. Fee terms are set out in a written retainer agreement before any work begins.
Talk to a New York Slip and Fall Lawyer
The evidence that proves notice has a short life. Surveillance video gets overwritten, spills get cleaned, ice melts, defects get repaired, and employees move on. A preservation letter sent in the first week is often what makes a case provable months later.
Call 518-274-5820 or use our contact form. Consultations are free and we handle slip and fall cases on a contingency fee basis.
Hacker Murphy LLP
- Troy: 64 2nd Street, Suite 101, Troy, NY 12180
- Albany: 22 Corporate Woods Blvd., Suite 404, Albany, NY 12211
- Schenectady: 670 Franklin Street, Suite 200, Schenectady, NY 12305
- Saratoga Springs: 511 Broadway, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866
Phone: 518-274-5820
See our personal injury practice and case results.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The information on this page is general information about New York law and is not legal advice. Reading this page or contacting Hacker Murphy LLP does not create an attorney-client relationship.